Insurance Basics

    How to Choose an Insurance Agent: Independent vs Captive

    Get a Personalized Quote

    Fill out your information and we'll get back to you with options tailored to your situation.

    One of the most important decisions in your insurance shopping process is who helps you. Here's what to know about different types of agents.

    Captive Agents

    A captive agent represents one insurance company exclusively. They can only sell that company's products.

    • Pros: Deep knowledge of their company's products, direct relationship with the insurer
    • Cons: Can only offer one company's plans - if a competitor has a better option for you, they can't show it to you

    Independent Agents

    An independent agent represents multiple insurance companies and can compare options across carriers.

    • Pros: Can show you plans from dozens of companies, provide unbiased comparisons, find the best fit for your situation
    • Cons: May not have the deepest expertise with any single carrier

    How Agents Get Paid

    Most health and life insurance agents are compensated by the insurance company - not by you. This means there's typically no cost to you for working with an agent. The plan costs the same whether you buy it directly or through an agent.

    What to Look For

    • Licensed in your state (and nationally, if you want someone who understands plans across states)
    • Independent (unless you specifically want one company's products)
    • Experienced with your specific type of insurance need
    • Someone who educates you rather than pressures you

    Have Questions?

    I'm happy to walk you through your options. No obligation, no pressure.

    Nick Depke, licensed insurance agent in Omaha, NE

    About the author

    Nick Depke, Licensed Insurance Agent (NPN 19158595)

    Nick Depke is a licensed independent insurance agent in Omaha, Nebraska, helping families compare Medicare, health, life, and supplemental plans from 200+ carriers. Consultations are always free.

    Nick Depke

    Have a Quick Medicare Question? Just Text Me.

    No hold music. No call center. Just text your question to (402) 680-6171 and I'll personally respond, usually same day.

    Call or Text: (402) 680-6171

    You Might Also Like

    From missing enrollment periods to choosing the cheapest plan without understanding the tradeoffs - these mistakes can cost thousands. Here's how to avoid them.

    Read More

    Deductible, coinsurance, copay, out-of-pocket maximum - insurance jargon can be confusing. Here's every term you need to know, explained simply.

    Read More

    Ready to Find the Right Coverage? Get a Free Quote

    Tell me about your situation and I'll research the best options for you - no obligation, no pressure. Takes about 3 minutes.

    Nick DepkeText Nick a Question
    Text Now