Omaha, Nebraska
Who Are the Best Health Insurance Agents in Omaha?
A side-by-side look at Omaha-area health insurance agents and brokers, based on publicly available information.
Omaha, Nebraska
Your Local Independent Agent Serving Omaha, Nebraska
Nick Depke - independent broker, top-rated locally, zero-pressure guidance from someone who actually answers the phone.
What I help with
Medicare AdvantageMedicare SupplementACA MarketplaceSelf-EmployedTurning 65Life InsuranceDental & VisionGroup / ICHRA
See ACA Plans YourselfBrowse & enroll on your ownGet My RecommendationNick picks the best plan for you
Licensed independent broker · NPN 19158595 · No fees, ever
If you are shopping for health insurance in Omaha, the agent you choose matters more than most people expect. Below is a list of Omaha-area health insurance agents and brokers based on publicly available information. This list is in no particular order. Depke Insurance Agency is included because we wrote this page and it would be dishonest to leave ourselves out. Hold us to the same standard as everyone else.
Jonathan Jacobi, HealthMarkets Insurance Agency
BBB: Not confirmed
Medicare
ACA / Marketplace
Self-employed health
Life
Dental / Vision
Supplemental
Employee Benefits
"Shortly after graduating from the University of Nebraska in 2005, I joined HealthMarkets. I spend the majority of my time consulting individuals, families, and business owners. HealthMarkets searches thousands of plans from more than 200 insurance companies to find the coverage that is right for you."
Phone: 402-517-0732
Website: healthmarkets.com
Independent: HealthMarkets-affiliated broker
In-person: Office listed (17310 Wright St, Ste 100)
In business since: With HealthMarkets since 2005 (~20 years)
Google: Active profile
Annual review: Not specified on site
Health & Life Insurance Pros
BBB: Not confirmed
ACA / Marketplace
Medicare
Self-employed health
Dental
Vision
Life
Hospital Indemnity
"We are not tied to one company and we do not push one-size-fits-all plans. You will get a personal broker who works with you year-round. We provide free annual policy reviews, 24/7 concierge support, and real local service from specialists who know Nebraska's health insurance landscape."
Phone: 402-303-4933
Website: healthandlifepros.com
Independent: Yes, confirmed
In-person: By appointment only
In business since: Lead broker 15 years in insurance
Google: 10 reviews · 4.9 rating
Annual review: Yes, explicitly offered
Strategic Benefits
BBB: Accredited · A+
ACA / Marketplace
Self-employed health
Employer Group
Level-funded plans
"We are a Marketplace-certified broker focused on employer benefits and self-employed family health plans. We have been recognized as an Elite Circle of Champions recipient by the Federal Health Insurance Marketplace for 10+ years. Best of Omaha winner 2022, 2023, and 2024."
Phone: 402-740-1530
Website: strategicben.com
Independent: Broker / Marketplace-certified
In-person: By appointment only
In business since: 2014 (~10 years); principal 20+ years experience
Google: 52 reviews · 5.0 rating
Annual review: Not specified on site
Depke Insurance Agency, Nick Depke
(This page)BBB: Accredited · A+
Medicare
ACA / Marketplace
Self-employed health
Life
Dental / Vision
Supplemental
Employer Group
"We are an independent broker representing 200+ carriers across Medicare, ACA Marketplace, self-employed health, life, dental, vision, supplemental, and employer group coverage. Consultations are free and paid by the carriers. We serve self-employed individuals, small business owners, families, and Medicare beneficiaries across Nebraska. After enrollment, we stay involved, annual plan reviews, Special Enrollment Period help, and year-round support are all part of what we do."
Phone: 402-680-6171
Website: depkeinsuranceagency.com
Independent: Yes, confirmed (200+ carriers)
In-person: Office + virtual available
Languages: English
In business since: 2019 (~6 years)
Google: 53 reviews · 5.0 rating
Annual review: Yes, explicitly offered
Insurance Advisors, The Lisa Wilsey Agency
BBB: Accredited
Medicare Advantage
Medicare Supplement
ACA
Medicaid navigation
Life
Cancer plans
"We are located in the Old Mill Shopping Center and serve clients across Nebraska, Iowa, and South Dakota. We currently offer 73 Medicare plans. Lisa Wilsey is an independent licensed insurance agent and is not affiliated with or endorsed by the government or the federal Medicare program."
Phone: 402-955-9233
Website: askinsuranceadvisors.com
Independent: Yes, confirmed
In-person: Office listed (10868 W Dodge Rd)
In business since: Not specified on site
Google: 6 reviews · 5.0 rating
Annual review: Not specified on site
Oracle Insurance Agency
BBB: Not confirmed
Medicare
ACA
Group Health
Dental / Vision
Hospital Indemnity
Home / Auto / Business
"We are an independent agency, not captive to any single carrier. Oracle Insurance started in 2011 and is still family-owned and operated. Our team of experienced agents works with you on a one-on-one basis to develop not only the right policy, but a lasting relationship."
Phone: 402-614-6623
Website: oracleinsuranceagency.com
Independent: Yes, confirmed
In-person: Office listed (9829 S 168th, Ste 4B)
Languages: English + Spanish
In business since: 2011 (~14 years)
Google: 41 reviews · 4.5 rating
Annual review: Policy review offered
All Lines Insurance
BBB: Not confirmed
Health
Medicare Supplement
Life
Dental / Vision
Home / Auto / Business
"Serving Nebraska and Iowa since 2007, family and locally-owned All Lines Insurance represents over 50 companies. Our independent insurance agents shop the many carriers we work with to get you the best insurance for your needs and budget."
Phone: 402-614-0909
Website: alllinesomaha.com
Independent: Yes, confirmed (50+ carriers)
In-person: Office listed (2722 S 114th St)
Languages: English + Spanish
In business since: 2007 (~18 years)
Google: 36 reviews · 4.8 rating
Annual review: General service language
Disclaimer: Informational purposes only. This page is based on publicly available data from agency websites, Google Business listings, and third-party directories as of early 2026. It is not a ranking, endorsement, or solicitation. Phone numbers, websites, and service details may change. BBB status reflects publicly available accreditation data and may change over time. Verify all information directly with any agent before making coverage decisions.
FAQ, Health Insurance Agents in Omaha
Look for an independent (not captive) agent who is licensed in Nebraska and works with multiple carriers. Independent agents compare plans across companies rather than selling a single carrier's products. Check Google reviews, ask about their experience with ACA subsidies and enrollment, and make sure they don't charge you, legitimate agents are paid by carriers, not clients.
No. Licensed health insurance agents and brokers are paid commissions by the insurance carriers, not by clients. The plans cost the same whether you enroll directly, through Healthcare.gov, or through an agent. Working with an agent gives you free expert guidance with no markup on your premiums.
A captive agent works for one company (like a UnitedHealthcare or Humana representative) and can only sell that carrier's plans. An independent agent or broker is licensed with multiple carriers and can compare options across the entire market. For health insurance, independent agents typically offer more choices and unbiased recommendations.
Yes. A licensed health insurance agent can estimate your subsidy, help you choose the right metal tier, and complete your Healthcare.gov application. The agent's help is free, and using an agent doesn't affect your subsidy amount. In fact, agents often find savings clients miss when applying on their own.
Both get you the same plans at the same prices. But a local agent understands Nebraska-specific carrier networks, knows which hospitals are in-network, can meet in person, and provides ongoing support when you need to use your insurance. According to NAHU, 43% of marketplace enrollees who used an agent reported higher satisfaction than those who enrolled alone.
Ready to Talk Through Your Options?
Depke Insurance Agency is an independent broker representing 200+ carriers across Medicare, ACA Marketplace, self-employed health, employer group, life, and supplemental. Consultations are free, paid by the carriers, not you. NPN: 19158595.